PDA

View Full Version : ID and Sexing Help Needed


Katalyst
Jul 21st 2007, 06:54 PM
http://i102.photobucket.com/albums/m103/katalyst_x/cory3.jpg
http://i102.photobucket.com/albums/m103/katalyst_x/cory2.jpg
http://i102.photobucket.com/albums/m103/katalyst_x/cory1.jpg

There I am at the LFS getting some calcium sand as part of a snail experiment..And of course I have to look at the fish section for new cories. At the same time this little boy and his mother are looking at the tanks as well...Wouldn't you know I spot a tank that says c. juli and there are 3 little guys in a completely bare tank cowering in the corner. :( The kid is begging his mother for them as I'm thinking do I feel like paying $12.99 a piece for juli's that are prolly not juli's? And I thought nahhh Then mother says oh all right lets go find a bowl....A bowl?? I'm anti bowl because of all the poor goldies thrown into bowls. So of course being the sucker, here they are. Worse case scenario my 3 lone c. trilineatus will finally have buddies.

So are they c. trilineatus or juli's? Any idea of the sex's??? I can't even sex my apple snails yet forget about cories.

P.S.
Yes I am aware that I have no self control.

Katalyst
Jul 22nd 2007, 06:19 PM
Had a little help at the ID...

As I suspected c.trilineatus! And 3 males! :cry: :POed:Hopefully the one of the other 3 that I have is a female.

Melody
Jul 22nd 2007, 07:20 PM
When I shop for Cory's I use a little trick if I can't sex them. I get the smallest and the largest in the tank - I usually end up with both sexes then. So far it hasn't failed me anyways.

Katalyst
Jul 22nd 2007, 07:35 PM
When I shop for Cory's I use a little trick if I can't sex them. I get the smallest and the largest in the tank - I usually end up with both sexes then. So far it hasn't failed me anyways.

These were the only 3 in the tank unfortunately...But I do have 3 more that are all the same darn size as well..... 6 males??? gah!

Melody
Jul 22nd 2007, 08:35 PM
Its not fool-proof - works best when they're young. Mr. Madattiver could probably give you something more definite. Don't know where that guy has been hiding :Think: ...

madattiver
Jul 25th 2007, 10:50 AM
I am sorry to say that these guys you have are one of the harder species to actually sex as the males and females look pretty close to the same. I have a group of 7 of these myself that I have had for a good part of 3 years and I still have no clue who is a guy and who is a girl. The only way I think I will be able to tell is when one has an egg in her ventrals and the other is chasing her.

Katalyst
Jul 25th 2007, 01:59 PM
I am sorry to say that these guys you have are one of the harder species to actually sex as the males and females look pretty close to the same. I have a group of 7 of these myself that I have had for a good part of 3 years and I still have no clue who is a guy and who is a girl. The only way I think I will be able to tell is when one has an egg in her ventrals and the other is chasing her.
I found one lone one in a pleco tank last night for $2.99 at BA's then again they usually give me a break since I do trades and am always in there. This one's smaller so I have 7 now myself and I've seen them shoaling in groups of around 10 and they look so happy so I'm hoping to find 3 females. Have they ever spawned for you?

I watched my peppereds spawing early this morning and it was pretty cool, there weren't many eggs though that I can see anyways and what I did see they ate. But they did seem like a bit of a trigger as there was a lot of chasing. I got a few pictures of the female holding her eggs which I'll post later. Thanks for the advice.

madattiver
Jul 25th 2007, 02:07 PM
these are actually one species that I have yet to spawn... I have spawned 18 other species... but hoping to add this to the list one of these days

Katalyst
Jul 25th 2007, 02:25 PM
18??????? :swoon:

:eek: Man I'm jealous! Here I'm lucky if I see peppered, and c.trilineatus usually sells out within one day as of shipment..Mainly I see green and golds and albino's which I have as well. The lfs all sell c.tril's as juli' which gets old but what can you do? Except in the Big A's near me the fish guys there are pretty decent. And when they don't know something they are pretty receptive and interested in learning something new.

Can you suggest anyone in Ontario/Canada in general that breeds/ships? I've posted a few ad's but so far no dice.

madattiver
Jul 25th 2007, 04:09 PM
trust me.. it is the same here.. almost all my fish I have came from out of town orders or other hobbiests throughout the years. I am lucky to find anything beyond paleatus, aeneus, panda or trilineatus here as well.

btw.. I just got 5 corydoras loxozonus and 6 corydoras davidsandsi sent to me the other day.. ::D:

jordonsmum
Jul 25th 2007, 05:24 PM
http://i102.photobucket.com/albums/m103/katalyst_x/cory3.jpg
http://i102.photobucket.com/albums/m103/katalyst_x/cory2.jpg
http://i102.photobucket.com/albums/m103/katalyst_x/cory1.jpg

There I am at the LFS getting some calcium sand as part of a snail experiment..And of course I have to look at the fish section for new cories. At the same time this little boy and his mother are looking at the tanks as well...Wouldn't you know I spot a tank that says c. juli and there are 3 little guys in a completely bare tank cowering in the corner. :( The kid is begging his mother for them as I'm thinking do I feel like paying $12.99 a piece for juli's that are prolly not juli's? And I thought nahhh Then mother says oh all right lets go find a bowl....A bowl?? I'm anti bowl because of all the poor goldies thrown into bowls. So of course being the sucker, here they are. Worse case scenario my 3 lone c. trilineatus will finally have buddies.

So are they c. trilineatus or juli's? Any idea of the sex's??? I can't even sex my apple snails yet forget about cories.

P.S.
Yes I am aware that I have no self control.

I'm proud of your choice. Thanks for helpin out the little guys. You know they appreciate it!!! Think of the fate they could have had:(

Melody
Jul 25th 2007, 07:29 PM
trust me.. it is the same here.. almost all my fish I have came from out of town orders or other hobbiests throughout the years. I am lucky to find anything beyond paleatus, aeneus, panda or trilineatus here as well.

btw.. I just got 5 corydoras loxozonus and 6 corydoras davidsandsi sent to me the other day.. ::D:

You'll just have to supply everyone then ::D:

Katalyst
Jul 25th 2007, 10:23 PM
You'll just have to supply everyone then ::D:

That's whay I'm sayin'

Melody
Jul 25th 2007, 10:26 PM
I'm hearing the NY accent in that statement...lol... know what I'm sayin'?:;):

Katalyst
Jul 25th 2007, 10:35 PM
I'm hearing the NY accent in that statement...lol... know what I'm sayin'?:;):
[Taxi driver]Are you talkin' to me? [/Taxi Driver]

There's even a sign as you drive into New York City from Jersey that the former Mayor had created...

It says

Welcome to New York
Fuhhhhghetiaboutttitt

God I love Juliani! The man seriously needs to run for President.

Melody
Jul 26th 2007, 06:47 PM
I can't imagine what you'll sound like in five years - combo of Canuck and NY accents.

Know what I'm sayin' eh?